The Dumpster Dive 🗑️

Every card below has three or fewer PSA 10s in existence — a few have exactly ONE. Decades of grading, thousands of submissions, and that's all the gems the hobby has ever found. Which means somewhere out there — a shoebox, an attic, a garage-sale binder, the bottom of a toy chest — the next gem copy is still hiding. Who's going to find it first?

Reward = what the next gem would likely fetch: the card's own PSA 10 market value where one has actually traded, otherwise our estimate at 6× its PSA 9 value — the median premium ultra-scarce vintage gems (pop 1–3) really command. Think you've got one? Scan it before you even breathe on it.

ONLY 1 EXISTS

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Nasty Nick #1

1986 · Garbage Pail Kids Giant Stickers

109 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 1

REWARD ~$920

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1986, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 1 EXISTS

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Muggin' Megan #42b

1985 · Garbage Pail Kids Stickers

91 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 1

REWARD ~$390

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1985, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 1 EXISTS

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Repaired Rex #174b

1986 · Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 5

52 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 1

REWARD: NAME YOUR PRICE

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1986, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 2 EXIST

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Vile Kyle #47b

1985 · Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 2

56 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 2

REWARD ~$1,940

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1985, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 2 EXIST

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Rappin' Ron #46a

1985 · Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 2

93 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 2

REWARD ~$890

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1985, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 2 EXIST

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Rappin' Ron #46a

1985 · Garbage Pail Kids Stickers

52 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 2

REWARD ~$660

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1985, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 2 EXIST

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Duncan Pumpkin #153b

1986 · Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 4

56 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 2

REWARD: NAME YOUR PRICE

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1986, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 3 EXIST

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Semi Colin No Card Number #0

1987 · Garbage Pail Kids Stickers

216 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 3

REWARD ~$10,580

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1987, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

ONLY 3 EXIST

WANTED

GEM MINT COPY · ARMED WITH
RAZOR-SHARP CORNERS

Semi Colin No Card Number #355b

1987 · Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 9

217 copies graded · PSA 10s ever: 3

REWARD: NAME YOUR PRICE

est. price of the next gem found

LAST SEEN: 1987, mint fresh inside a wax pack.
Approach with soft sleeves and steady hands.

Population figures come from the live grading census (full-census cards only) and update continuously — when someone finally gems one of these, its poster updates automatically. Reward estimates are estimates: the first-of-its-kind auction could go far higher. Happy diving. 🗑️💎